
“Education leads to enlightenment. Enlightenment paves the way for empathy. Empathy heralds reform”. In his book “Faces at the Bottom of the Well: The Permanence of Racism,” the late Harvard law professor Dr. Derrick Bell disputes this quote and the idea that education can lead to social reform, particularly in the matter of racism. Bell therefore questions the idea that understanding racial discrimination will automatically lead to the elimination of racist attitudes, emphasizing that racial progress is not guaranteed. He sees racism as a deeply rooted material interest, difficult to eradicate through education, and describes it as a complex mix of guilt, responsibility, and power. I agree with this perspective.
In February, Canada is highlighting the history of Africans uprooted by slavery to highlight the importance of black history in the fight for racial justice. However, I advocate for greater attention to the connection between history and current systemic oppression, arguing that black resistance should not be limited to one month but recognized year-round as an ongoing effort for equality and justice. In the wake of the tragic killing of George Floyd in 2020, the notion of "allyship" in the social justice activism movement has gained prominence. However, this notion is sometimes tainted by a lack of sincerity and the danger of adopting purely performative behavior.
In 2022, during Black History Month, our organization the Red Coalition had denounced an incident that occurred in a high school in Longueuil, which highlighted the pressing need to combat racial stereotypes. A white parent felt troubled by a French assignment given to her seventh-grade daughter, which stereotypically presented a "gangster" as a racialized person, using images that reinforce negative stereotypes. Despite his complaints, he was surprised to learn that this assignment had been used by this teacher for three years without eliciting reactions from anyone.
A year later, still during Black History Month in 2023, the Red Coalition had denounced a private college in Rigaud, Quebec, for systemic racism and discrimination, particularly against black students who faced daily racism, including physical and verbal abuse, sometimes in front of staff. Despite the complaints, the school failed to act. The Red Coalition's intervention demanded immediate action to eliminate racism and ensure a safe and inclusive environment, leading the school to agree to their demands.
Despite these challenges, I emphasize the critical importance for allies to inform themselves and leverage their privileged position to support others. A 2021 survey by the Angus Reid Institute found that 58% of young Canadians, including white students, have witnessed racial bullying in school. This alarming observation highlights a lack of awareness and a certain reluctance from the teaching staff to fight against racism. I am pleading here for the implementation of concrete initiatives aimed at creating truly inclusive educational environments, where every child feels respected and valued.
To highlight the importance of Dr. Bell's point, I believe it is crucial to recognize that in the fight against racism, allyship plays an invaluable role. However, it is essential to understand that being an ally goes beyond simply declaring yourself non-racist. A true alliance requires a commitment to active anti-racism.
Dear allies, your actions are crucial. When you witness race-based discrimination, it is imperative to speak up and report it. If you encounter someone who makes racist remarks, challenge them. If you encounter a racist joke, don't laugh at it - on the contrary, denounce it and report it. Your proactive stance is vital to fostering a more inclusive and equitable society.
By Alain Babineau.
Alain (Al) Babineau retired as a Staff Sergeant from the Royal Canadian Mounted Police in 2016 after 30 years of service as a police officer. He holds a Juris Doctor and a Bachelor of Civil Law from the McGill Faculty of Law, as well as other degrees in criminology and conflict resolution. Currently, he is pursuing a master’s in law at McGill and holds leadership positions in organizations related to public security and the defense of the rights of Afro-descendants and minorities.
